Image Unavailable

Image not available for
Color:

To view this video download Flash Player

Visit the Johnston & Murphy Store

Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Cap Toe | Formal Dress Shoe

853 ratings

| Search this page

Price:

$166.46 $184.95 Free Returns on some sizes and colors

Color: Black Calfskin

Size Chart

US MEN SHOES

Brand Size	EU Size	AU Size	JP Size
6	38	5	24
6.5	38.5	5.5	24.5
7	39	6	25
7.5	40	6.5	25.5
8	41	7	26
8.5	41.5	7.5	26.5
9	42	8	27
9.5	42.5	8.5	27.5
10	43	9	28
10.5	43.5	9.5	28.5
11	44	10	29
11.5	45	10.5	29.5
12	46	11	30
13	47	12	31
14	48	13	32
15	49	14	33
16	50	15	34

Product details

Fabric type

100% Leather
Origin

Imported
Sole material

Leather
Outer material

Rubber

About this item

PREMIUM LEATHER: The Johnston & Murphy Melton Cap Toe is a timeless and classic shoe that will never go out of style. Crafted with hand-selected European leather for a premium look and feel.
TIMELESS CLASSIC STYLE: The Melton Cap Toe is a timeless classic you will want to wear for any memorable occasion including weddings, interviews, or graduation . Complete with a leather sole and combination stacked leather/Fineline rubber heel for a clean, dressy appearance.
OPTIMA COMFORT SYSTEM: The exclusive Optima Comfort System with multi-layered cushioning is engineered for optimal comfort, support, and flexibility.
GOODYEAR WELT: The Goodyear welt construction is a traditional method that allows for this style to be resoled by a cobber.
JOHNSTON & MURPHY: Founded in 1850, Johnston & Murphy prides itself on making modern classics at an exceptional value. Featuring a range of timeless styles from classic to casual, we are sure to have you looking good from head to toe.

New on Amazon: KIKO Milano

Iconic makeup designed in Italy Shop now

From the brand

How did we get our start?

In 1850, William Dudley, a master English shoemaker, began crafting shoes out of his home in Newark, New Jersey. Thirty years later, James Johnston joined as a partner helping to create a line of durable, high fashion footwear. Style and superior craftsmanship was a winning combination. Eventually, Johnston partnered with William Murphy—and the Johnston & Murphy name quickly came to stand for the highest quality shoes in America.
What makes our products unique?

Our secret to modern classics is simple — the magic is in the making. Finishes that are foremost, leather & other materials that stand out as better and every last stitch considered. Our inspiration comes from everywhere, but when it comes to style, we use a distinctly American lens to shape our point of view.
Why do we love what we do?

A great pair of shoes lets you walk into the world with confidence. For over a century and a half, J & M has been outfitting legends, leaders (including every U.S. president since Millard Filmore) and discerning individuals with a way to step up and stand out. We are proud to put our name on everything we do.
Fresh for Spring

Visit the Store

Product Description

johnston and murphy, johnston and murphy mens shoes, xc4, prentiss, conard, aragon, mcguffey, holden

SHOP FOOTWEAR

Shop our best-selling casuals, unmatched styled footwear that is engineered for maximum comfort, performance waterproof construction, and richly textured leather.

johnston and murphy mens shoes, mens shoes, johnston murphy shoes, mens shoes

johnston and murphy shirts, dress shirts, mens business shirts, johnston murphy shirts

SHOP APPAREL

Shop Johnston & Murphy men's section for a wide selection of dress shirts, casual shirts, sweaters, blazers, chinos, and more.

johnston and murphy mens shoes, johnston murphy, johnston and murphy dress shirts, dress shirt, j&m

Product details

Product Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 14.25 x 8.25 x 5.5 inches; 1.1 Pounds
Item model number ‏ : ‎ 22-2981
Department ‏ : ‎ mens
Date First Available ‏ : ‎ April 2, 2007
Manufacturer ‏ : ‎ Jos. A. Bank Clothiers
ASIN ‏ : ‎ B000UUILV0

Best Sellers Rank: #253,495 in Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry (See Top 100 in Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry)
- #565 in Men's Oxfords

Customer Reviews:
853 ratings

Top Brand: Johnston & Murphy

Highly Rated

10K+ customers rate items from this brand highly

Trending

10K+ orders for this brand in past 3 months

Low Returns

Customers usually keep items from this brand

WARNING: California’s Proposition 65

Customer reviews

853 global ratings

How customer reviews and ratings work

Review this product

Write a customer review

Customers say

Customers find these dress shoes to be well-made with Goodyear welted construction that holds up well during break-in, and appreciate their simple design and proper sizing. They are comfortable, with one customer noting they can dance all night without discomfort, and offer good value for money. The leather quality receives positive feedback for its softness and soles, though some customers find them quite stiff.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Select to learn more

Look Quality Fit Comfort Shoe quality Value for money Leather quality Stiffness

260 customers mention "Look"245 positive15 negative

Customers appreciate the appearance of these shoes, describing them as the best-in-class and acceptable for office wear, with one customer noting their extremely rich and luxurious feel.

"...days, I've gotten up to two resoles from one pair, with the top half still looking good...." Read more

"...These are truly a handsome pair of shoes...." Read more

"...Things I like about these shoes: +Classic cap toe style +Great fit that improves over time +Goodyear welt = easy re-sole..." Read more

"This is my second pair of this product. It is durable, Stylish and holds it shape for years. Everywhere I go I receive great comments on my shoes." Read more

239 customers mention "Quality"192 positive47 negative

Customers praise the construction of these shoes, noting their Goodyear welted soles that hold up well during the break-in period, with uppers expected to last several years.

"...Just pick one up and look at and you can see the quality in the shoe. They cost more, and they are worth it...." Read more

"This is my second pair of this product. It is durable, Stylish and holds it shape for years. Everywhere I go I receive great comments on my shoes." Read more

"...The shoes have all been extremely well made, and have retained their shape, their comfort and their tight stitching after many years." Read more

"...On paper these are a no brainer--welted construction, calf leather, leather sole, and a low price...." Read more

233 customers mention "Fit"164 positive69 negative

Customers find these shoes comfortable and properly sized, with one customer noting that the 3E width works well for an XW foot.

"...Park Avenue, which seems to be a different last, but that shoe fit perfectly and was comfortable with minimal breaking in (though at quite a premium)..." Read more

"...Things I like about these shoes: +Classic cap toe style +Great fit that improves over time +Goodyear welt = easy re-sole..." Read more

"The width was too small." Read more

"...well made, and have retained their shape, their comfort and their tight stitching after many years." Read more

210 customers mention "Comfort"163 positive47 negative

Customers find these shoes comfortable, noting that their feet don't hurt while wearing them, and one customer mentions being able to dance all night without discomfort.

"...Lately I have found a new use for these sturdy, comfortable shoes with leather soles ... dancing shoes!..." Read more

"...a different last, but that shoe fit perfectly and was comfortable with minimal breaking in (though at quite a premium)...." Read more

"...all been extremely well made, and have retained their shape, their comfort and their tight stitching after many years." Read more

"...more prone to scuffing and wear than the Minzer and the shoe while comfortable has a couple of pressure points that require you to adjust your foot..." Read more

125 customers mention "Shoe quality"114 positive11 negative

Customers find these shoes to be excellent, particularly as dress shoes, with one customer noting they are a great entry-level option.

"...For the price they are one of the better dress shoes available. I purchased in my typical size, 11D, and they fit as expected...." Read more

"...Bottom line, it's a good basic shoe to start with (certainly better than 50 dollar square-toed Cole Haan abominations), but if you can possibly..." Read more

"The product was good. The problem is the actual color was not as shown in the add." Read more

"...To summarize: A great professional shoe with best-in-class looks but very uncomfortable when breaking-in." Read more

119 customers mention "Value for money"106 positive13 negative

Customers find these shoes to be a good value for the money.

"...They cost more, and they are worth it. I prefer the 100% leather soles and J&M is one of the few brands that carry that...." Read more

"...a no brainer--welted construction, calf leather, leather sole, and a low price...." Read more

"...so I consider these a satisfactory substitute and excellent value for shoppers on a budget." Read more

"Worth the buy." Read more

112 customers mention "Leather quality"89 positive23 negative

Customers appreciate the leather quality of these shoes, noting their wonderful soles and soft texture, with one customer specifically mentioning their suitability for dancing.

"...They cost more, and they are worth it. I prefer the 100% leather soles and J&M is one of the few brands that carry that...." Read more

"...The leather was flawless and the stitching all looked good. These are truly a handsome pair of shoes...." Read more

"...+Goodyear welt = easy re-sole +Leather takes a shine well Cons are few: -The tongue is sewn on one side to keep it in place...." Read more

"...--Weather-resistance unlike most dance shoes. --Resolable leather sole. --A leather lining...." Read more

73 customers mention "Stiffness"6 positive67 negative

Customers find the shoes stiff, comparing them to rigid plastic and pleather.

"...They are quite stiff, which is to be expected from a shoe of this quality and construction, and I expect they will take some time to break in..." Read more

"...I agree that the leather uppers are firm on arrival, but that's what I expect from a brand new pair of leather shoes...." Read more

"...These are very stiff shoes with thick soles which you may never break in if you only use them in the office...." Read more

"...small complaint I have is that the laces look really cheap and feel plasticy...." Read more

Reviews with images

See all photos

Top reviews from the United States

There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.

Purchased Product
The Best Men's Dress Shoe
Reviewed in the United States on November 20, 2024
Size: 11Color: Tan CalfskinVerified Purchase

I have worn Johnston and Murphy for many years. Just pick one up and look at and you can see the quality in the shoe. They cost more, and they are worth it. I prefer the 100% leather soles and J&M is one of the few brands that carry that. In my more frugal days, I've gotten up to two resoles from one pair, with the top half still looking good. Lately I have found a new use for these sturdy, comfortable shoes with leather soles ... dancing shoes! Once I bought a J&M dress shoe, I never considered another brand.

Read more

Helpful

Report
Greg K.
First Impressions with an Update
Reviewed in the United States on December 28, 2016
Verified Purchase
Update: I measured 11.5 C on the Brannock device, and so I ordered these in 11.5 C and while I initially thought they were appropriately sized, the heel rubbing did not improve with continued wear. After getting sized in a store, I would have to say these are too large for me and I am better suited to 10.5 D in the Aristocraft line, and probably an 11 D in the Melton line, though I am still not entirely satisfied with the fit. I was fitted for an 10EEE Allen Edmonds Park Avenue, which seems to be a different last, but that shoe fit perfectly and was comfortable with minimal breaking in (though at quite a premium). For additional comparison, I wear an 11.5 in Adidas Sambas and typically a 10.5 in Bass Oxfords.

The color, finish, etc. are all accurately represented in the photographs and description. The leather was flawless and the stitching all looked good. These are truly a handsome pair of shoes.

When they arrived, I wore them around the house for a few hours and then let them rest for a couple of days. They are quite stiff, which is to be expected from a shoe of this quality and construction, and I expect they will take some time to break in properly. My commute to work is a little over half a mile, so I was somewhat apprehensive of wearing them for a full day after minimal breaking in. I did develop a couple of hot spots on the backs of my ankles from rubbing, but applied some self-adhesive bandages, which prevented blistering, and they were otherwise comfortable for the rest of the day.

I will try to remember to check back and update after I have had a chance to break them in. All in all, my first impressions are highly favorable and I look forward to their continued use.

Read more

5 people found this helpful

Helpful

Report
CS
Great shoe!
Reviewed in the United States on July 11, 2015
Verified Purchase
**UPDATE 11/14** J&M replaced the shoes. Their customer service is superb. Yet to try out the replacements, but they are starting out in perfect shape.

**UPDATE 9/9** Not as pleased with these shoes as I was at first. I have sent an email to J&M Customer Service with the second picture attached. The shoes Bordeaux version are developing significant wrinkling/cracking on the vamp after 10-15 wears.

Original review:
These are great shoes. I have them in both Bordeaux and Tan. In order to really enjoy these shoes I recommend a couple of things right out of the box. First, woodlore shoe trees. Next, make sure they are free of dust and debris and hit them with some Saphir conditioner and a couple of rounds of shoe polish. Google The Shoe Snob's blog for suggestions on polishing.

Things I like about these shoes:
+Classic cap toe style
+Great fit that improves over time
+Goodyear welt = easy re-sole
+Leather takes a shine well

Cons are few:
-The tongue is sewn on one side to keep it in place. Some people like this, I do not. This is easily rectified with a knife and steady hands
-There are a couple of spots that are discolored from something in the manufacturing process (possibly glue). It does not come off with cleaner. From six feet up in the air, these flaws aren't noticeable, but they are apparent up close.

Read more

CS

Great shoe!

Reviewed in the United States on July 11, 2015
**UPDATE 11/14** J&M replaced the shoes. Their customer service is superb. Yet to try out the replacements, but they are starting out in perfect shape.

**UPDATE 9/9** Not as pleased with these shoes as I was at first. I have sent an email to J&M Customer Service with the second picture attached. The shoes Bordeaux version are developing significant wrinkling/cracking on the vamp after 10-15 wears.

Original review:
These are great shoes. I have them in both Bordeaux and Tan. In order to really enjoy these shoes I recommend a couple of things right out of the box. First, woodlore shoe trees. Next, make sure they are free of dust and debris and hit them with some Saphir conditioner and a couple of rounds of shoe polish. Google The Shoe Snob's blog for suggestions on polishing.

Things I like about these shoes:
+Classic cap toe style
+Great fit that improves over time
+Goodyear welt = easy re-sole
+Leather takes a shine well

Cons are few:
-The tongue is sewn on one side to keep it in place. Some people like this, I do not. This is easily rectified with a knife and steady hands
-There are a couple of spots that are discolored from something in the manufacturing process (possibly glue). It does not come off with cleaner. From six feet up in the air, these flaws aren't noticeable, but they are apparent up close.

Images in this review

18 people found this helpful

Helpful

Report
AH
These Are Great Shoes
Reviewed in the United States on November 2, 2024
Size: 12 X-WideColor: Black CalfskinVerified Purchase
This is my second pair of this product. It is durable, Stylish and holds it shape for years. Everywhere I go I receive great comments on my shoes.

Read more

One person found this helpful

Helpful

Report
Father Of Two
After 18 years of use, repurchased same shoe
Reviewed in the United States on June 18, 2012
Size: 11Color: Black CalfskinVerified Purchase
I bought this exact same pair of shoes 18 years ago. Had them re-soled 3 times, replaced worn laces 6-7 times, but these shoes have remained in great shape. Recently the sole of these old shoes started coming detached, and scuff marks were getting more pronounced, so I decided it was finally time to replace.

The new shoes are beautiful, extremely professional looking, and very comfortable. Other reviewers have commented that it takes some time to break them in. I agree that the leather uppers are firm on arrival, but that's what I expect from a brand new pair of leather shoes. On first putting on my new pair of shoes, I can tell they are of the same quality and caliber of the ones I purchased 18 years ago.

I have two other pairs of Johnston & Murphy shoes - another style for work, and a different style for casual use. The shoes have all been extremely well made, and have retained their shape, their comfort and their tight stitching after many years.

Read more

18 people found this helpful

Helpful

Report
R. Vassel
Good but not great shoes
Reviewed in the United States on November 28, 2010
Verified Purchase
I have several pairs of J&M's Minzer Oxfords (which are comfortable), so I decided to try the Meltons based on other reviews (and admittedly because I thought since they were a little more expensive, the shoe would be even more comfortable than my Minzers). The shoe is a beautiful shoe, but it is actually slightly less comfortable than my Minzers. One thing I didn't expect was how the shoe fit when I first tried it on. It appeared at first that the shoes ran very narrow but after pushing with a little more force, I quickly discovered that the shoe is sized properly and that the initial difficulty I experienced is because the shoe is designed to fit the contour of the foot, which is something I appreciated as I have wide feet (E-2E) and this attribute makes them seem slimmer. I've worn the shoes several times and while they look dressier than the Minzer, the soles seem more prone to scuffing and wear than the Minzer and the shoe while comfortable has a couple of pressure points that require you to adjust your foot in the shoe. While I like the look of the Meltons, based on overall value I will stick with the Minzers from now on.

Read more

8 people found this helpful

Helpful

Report

Top reviews from other countries

Translate all reviews to English

Amazon Customer
Quality and Fit
Reviewed in Singapore on February 11, 2023
Size: 8Color: Tan CalfskinVerified Purchase

The shoes arrived on time and look great! They fit well when I first tried them on. I’m glad I selected the right size. The quality looks good and is reasonably priced for such a brand.

Read more
Report
Grigori Victorovich
xselent shoes worth the money
Reviewed in Canada on December 6, 2016
Size: 9.5 X-WideColor: Black CalfskinVerified Purchase
A pair of excellent shoes made in India for Johnston & Murphy. Everything about these shoes is beyond an ordinary praise: a very good quality and shiny uppers and leather sole, leather inlining and design. I have EEE wide feet and usually wear a size 9. These shoos in size 9 were too tight because the upper leather is quite stiff. I returned the size 9 and purchased a 9.5 size. This solved the problem: easy to put on although there is some spas in front of the toes. So, a I am very happy with the purchase and think the shoe are worth the prise.

Read more
Report
Alan
Larga vida y comodidad
Reviewed in Mexico on June 1, 2021
Size: 11 X-WideColor: Black CalfskinVerified Purchase
He tenido varios pares de esos zapatos, duran años y años.

Read more
Report
Translate review to English
Matthew G.
Good bang for the buck
Reviewed in Canada on May 12, 2017
Size: 11.5Color: Tan CalfskinVerified Purchase
The best shoes I've ever had are Allen Edmonds. Traditionally they've lasted for three to five years with an average of 100 wears per year. This is my first experience with this Johnston & Murphy and so far, I'd categorize them as 4/5s Allen Edmonds for 1/2 the price. The leather, wood and craftsmanship seem very good and they are quite comfortable. I believe they will last me three years assuming I use shoe trees and clean them regularly. I would classify them as great bang for the buck but I'll revisit this post in six months to confirm. On a side note, if you're like most of my colleagues, you buy $100 shoes and replace them every year. Personally, I'd rather buy better looking, more comfortable shoes for $200 that last me three years.

Read more
Report
Richard
The fit is perfect and quality appears to be good for the price ...
Reviewed in Canada on June 26, 2017
Size: 13Color: Tan CalfskinVerified Purchase
Shoes were delivered in a matter of days. The fit is perfect and quality appears to be good for the price paid.

Read more
Report

See more reviews

Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Cap Toe | Formal Dress Shoe

US MEN SHOES

Product details

About this item

Featured items to consider

From the brand

How did we get our start?

What makes our products unique?

Why do we love what we do?

Fresh for Spring

Product Description

SHOP FOOTWEAR

SHOP APPAREL

Product details

Videos

Videos for this product

Videos for this product

Videos for this product

Videos for this product

Top Brand: Johnston & Murphy

Customer reviews

Review this product

Customers say

Select to learn more

Images in this review

Reviews with images

Great shoe!

Top reviews from the United States

There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.

5.0 out of 5 stars The Best Men's Dress Shoe

5.0 out of 5 stars First Impressions with an Update

5.0 out of 5 stars Great shoe!

Great shoe!

Images in this review

5.0 out of 5 stars These Are Great Shoes

5.0 out of 5 stars After 18 years of use, repurchased same shoe

3.0 out of 5 stars Good but not great shoes

Top reviews from other countries

4.0 out of 5 stars Quality and Fit

5.0 out of 5 stars xselent shoes worth the money

5.0 out of 5 stars Larga vida y comodidad

5.0 out of 5 stars Good bang for the buck

5.0 out of 5 stars The fit is perfect and quality appears to be good for the price ...

The Best Men's Dress Shoe

First Impressions with an Update

Great shoe!

These Are Great Shoes

After 18 years of use, repurchased same shoe

Good but not great shoes

Quality and Fit

xselent shoes worth the money

Larga vida y comodidad

Good bang for the buck

The fit is perfect and quality appears to be good for the price ...